All dishes / North America
Clam chowder Period BOrigin theory CVerified
Some fields (dish name, region and gates) are shown from the Japanese-edition data.
New England clam chowder, the white shellfish soup, came together on a coast where the region's Native peoples had been simmering local clams since before colonization, joined by a pot-stew tradition brought from Europe. Its name, chowder, is most often taken to be a corruption of the French chaudière, meaning a cauldron, but the rival account that traces it to jowter, an English dialect word for a fishmonger, has not been ruled out.
Verification highlight popular claim → verdict → evidence
Myth: clam chowder is a purely American invention of New England. Verdict: that story leaves out the region's Native peoples, such as the Mohegan and Pequot, who were gathering and cooking clams before colonization; today's dish joined that tradition to a layered pot-stew brought from Europe. A chowder recipe printed in a Boston newspaper in 1751 calls for fish, pork, and biscuit, with no clams, potatoes, or milk. Clams enter a recipe by 1831 at the latest, in Lydia Maria Child's The Frugal Housewife, and only as "a pleasant addition" to a fish chowder whose liquid is flour and water rather than milk. The name chowder is most often traced to the French chaudière, a pot, with Breton fishermen said to have carried the custom by way of Newfoundland to New England. The first edition of the Oxford English Dictionary (1893) gives that derivation only as probable, and lists the dialect word jowter, a fish-hawker, under a separate heading without rejecting a link to chowder, so the jowter account has not been ruled out. Main sources: Online Etymology Dictionary; A New English Dictionary on Historical Principles (1893); L. M. Child, The Frugal Housewife (sixth edition, 1831); What's Cooking America; ICT News.
The three gates
- Ingredient-supply gate
- The lead ingredient, clams, is native to the North American Atlantic coast. Potatoes, dairy, and pork had all reached the region by colonial times, so none of them held the dish back. The firm of Burnham & Morrill was running a clam-canning factory at Blue Point in Scarborough, Maine, before 1869, and is said to have been the first company in the United States to turn clamming into a commercial business. After 1873 it moved to Pine Point, and in 1883 it and other companies canned and shipped 3,000 to 8,000 bushels of clams. The local-history account these figures come from does not say whether canned clams helped clam chowder spread inland.
- Cooking-technique gate
- A white chowder made with milk: salt pork is rendered for its fat, and the clams and potatoes are simmered in milk or cream. The recipe in L. M. Child's household book (The Frugal Housewife, sixth edition, 1831, p. 59) is different: it layers salt pork, fish, and crackers, onions, and thinly sliced potatoes, makes the liquid from flour and water with no milk, and treats clams only as an optional extra. The year a milk-based recipe first appears in a cookbook has not been established.
- Venue gate
- Cooked at home and served in eating houses, it was everyday food for ordinary people, and it belonged to the fishing villages of the coast.
Overview
A white soup from the shore
Clam chowder is a white soup of New England: clams as the star, simmered with potatoes, milk or cream, and salt pork. It is not known when a milk-based recipe like today's first appeared in a cookbook.
The clams at its heart are shellfish long native to the North American east coast. The region's Native peoples were simmering them before colonization, dropping heated stones into watertight vessels to cook the shellfish. The piles of shells that dotted the shoreline are said to show how much clams mattered in their diet. Potatoes, dairy, and pork had all reached this coast by colonial times.
Onto this came a pot-stewing method carried over from Europe: render fat from salt pork, then build up the pot in layers. It was a dish of the homes and eating houses of fishing villages, eaten by ordinary people along the coast.
How we know
Where the name chowder came from has long been debated between two accounts. One holds that jowter, an English dialect word for a fish peddler, turned into chowder. The other holds that it is a corruption of the French chaudière, meaning a cauldron or kettle.
Of these, etymological dictionaries take the derivation from French chaudière, a cauldron, a word in use since the twelfth century. Even so, the first edition of the Oxford English Dictionary, in its 1893 volume, gives the dish's name only as apparently of French origin, from chaudière. The same dictionary lists a dialect chowder or chowter as a variant of jowter, a fish-hawker, under a separate heading; it says nothing of a link to the dish's name, and it does not set the jowter account aside. On the chaudière account, Breton fishermen carried the habit of simmering in a cauldron to Newfoundland, and from there it passed through the Maritimes to New England. The dish is first recorded in North America in a Boston newspaper of 1751, but the chowder printed there is a simmer of fish, pork, and biscuit, with no clams, potatoes, or milk. The words "clam chowder" appear by 1822 at the latest. Clams enter a printed recipe by 1831 at the latest, in the household book of Lydia Maria Child, where "a few clams are a pleasant addition" to a fish chowder and the liquid is flour and water, not milk.
There is a second, often-erased backstory. Clam chowder is often told as "an American invention of New England," but the tradition of cooking and eating clams was here before colonization—it belonged to the Mohegan, Pequot, and other Native peoples of the land. Today's clam chowder is that old Native tradition of eating local clams joined to a layered pot-stew brought from Europe and to the name chowder. A story that strips out the Native tradition to make the dish a purely American invention oversimplifies that convergence.
The full set of origin theories and the detailed verification log — traceable all the way to their sources — are available on the Japanese edition.
See the full origin theories and verification log (Japanese) →